Zenlio Local · Compare

Your own site, or renting leads from Checkatrade and Bark.

Checkatrade, Bark, MyBuilder, Rated People. They'll get you enquiries fast, which is why so many trades start there. The catch is you're renting other people's customers, and the same lead lands with three or four rivals. Here's how that stacks up against a site that brings work direct to you.

The short version

A lead platform is rent. A website is a mortgage. One you own at the end, one you don't.

Pay Checkatrade or Bark every month and you get leads. Stop paying and you get nothing, because you never owned anything. Every pound went on renting a customer who was also being offered to the trade down the road.

That's fine as a fast start when you've got no site and no reviews. It's a poor deal as a forever plan. Spend three years and the thick end of £14,000 on a platform and you finish with exactly what you started with: nothing of your own.

The reason it works this way isn't a mystery. A lead platform's business model depends on selling the same enquiry to several trades at once and charging everyone for the chance, so the numbers only ever point one way for you: upward. A site you own doesn't have that problem built in, because nobody else is paying to sit in front of the same customer at the same time.

None of that makes the platforms bad businesses. It makes them a different kind of purchase. They're built to be rented forever, not owned outright, and understanding that difference upfront is most of what separates trades who use them well from trades who quietly bleed money on them for years without noticing.

A site you own works the other way round. It costs less each month, the enquiries come direct and unshared, and it gets stronger the longer it runs. Below is the full comparison, a couple of tools to help you work out where you actually stand, and the honest case for using both to begin with.

For the maths on what the platforms actually cost once you add it up, and a practical way to wean off them without cancelling anything tomorrow, see how to stop paying for every lead.

Which one fits you

Answer four honest questions.

No two trades are in the same spot. Answer these the way things actually are for you right now, not how you'd like them to be, and we'll give you a straight steer.

Click one card per question. There's no submit button, the verdict appears the moment all four are answered, and you can change any answer at any time.

Question 1 of 4

Do you already have any reviews or reputation online?

Question 2 of 4

Do you need work starting this week, or can you invest a few months building something long-term?

Question 3 of 4

How many leads are you currently buying a month?

Question 4 of 4

Would you rather compete on price against other quotes for the same job, or be the only one quoting?

Your steer

Keep renting, for now.

Based on what you've told us, a lead platform is still doing a fair job for you. No reviews yet, work needed quickly, and sharing the lead doesn't bother you much. That's exactly the situation these platforms are built for, and there's no shame in using one properly while that's true. Worth coming back to this page in six months, because for most trades this situation changes.

Talk to us when you're ready
Your steer

Run both, side by side.

You're in the middle ground where the sensible move is keeping the platform bringing work in while a site of your own gets built and starts ranking underneath it. Most trades we work with are exactly here: not ready to drop the platform outright, not content to rent forever either. It costs nothing to start the site running in parallel and see which one earns its keep.

See how the switch works
Your steer

Start building your own.

You've already got reviews, you can afford to play the long game, and you'd rather be the only quote in the room than one of five. That's the profile of someone paying to rent something they could own outright. A site built properly earns its cost back and keeps working long after a platform subscription would have run its course.

Get a free callback
Side by side

The honest comparison.

These platforms get the phone ringing fast, which is why so many trades start there. The catch is you're renting other people's customers: the same job you're quoting has usually landed with two or three others at the same time, so the "lead" is really a shared shot at winning work you might not get anyway. Where the platforms still earn their place, we say so below. Use the filters to jump to what matters most to you.

Checkatrade, Bark, MyBuilderZenlio LocalA site you own
What you're paying forThe chance to quote a lead.An asset that brings enquiries straight to you.
Who else gets the same leadTypically three to five other trades.Nobody. It's your enquiry, your customer.
Real cost£35 to £500 a month, plus £5 to £45 per lead. A busy month runs £400+.From £49 a month, all in, unlimited enquiries.
What you build over timeNothing. Stop paying and it's gone.Equity. A site that keeps working and grows.
Whose reputation it buildsTheirs. Their profile, their reviews, their rules.Yours. Your brand, your Google reviews, your name.
Price certaintyPriced by phone, and it climbs at renewal.Fixed, and shown in plain figures.
Found in Google and AI directNo. You sit inside their platform.Yes. Ranking for your own searches.
ExclusivityYou undercut everyone sent the same job.You're the one they found and called.

Competitor pricing reflects publicly reported UK figures at the time of writing and varies by trade, plan and location.

Do the sums

Cost per job, and your break-even point.

Drag the sliders to match roughly what you're paying now, or what you're weighing up. Everything below updates as you move them, so you can see exactly where the numbers cross over.

This uses the same pricing ranges already stated on this page: platform membership from £35 to £500 a month, per-lead fees from £5 to £45, and up to twenty leads bought a month. Set your Zenlio Local plan against it and watch the break-even point move.

Your platform, roughly

Starter£49/mo
Professional£79/mo
Growth£129/mo

What that means

Platform monthly total
£280
membership + leads × fee
Platform cost per lead, all in
£35
total spend ÷ leads bought
Zenlio Local, this plan
£79/mo
unlimited direct enquiries, no per-lead fee
Months to break even
5 months
then the build cost is fully recovered
Platform, 3 years£10,080
Zenlio Local, 3 years, build included£3,844

Figures are illustrative, based on the ranges already stated on this page, and meant to show the shape of the maths rather than predict your exact bill. Your own numbers will depend on your trade, area and how many leads you're realistically converting.

The honest bit

When a lead-gen site still earns its place.

We're not going to pretend these platforms are useless. Used right, they have a job to do.

🌱

When you're starting from nothing

No reviews, no site, no reputation yet. A lead platform gets you quoting work this week while you build something better underneath. That's a fair use of it.

📅

To fill a quiet week

Plenty of good trades keep one ticking over to plug gaps in the diary. As a top-up, fine. As your entire marketing, for years, is where it goes wrong.

The trap to avoid

Three years on Checkatrade at £400 a month is roughly £14,000, and you own nothing at the end of it. That same money builds and runs a site you own for a decade. Rent to start, then buy.

If you do keep a platform running, be deliberate about it. Point its bio or profile link at your own site or number wherever the platform allows it, so a customer who digs a little finds the same real business either way. The point isn't to hide that you're on there, it's to make sure the platform is feeding your reputation rather than quietly competing with it.

How to switch without a dead month

The transition, step by step.

Moving off a platform doesn't have to mean a gap in the diary. Most trades who do this well follow roughly the same path.

1

Weeks 1 to 4

Your site goes live. The platform keeps running exactly as before, nothing changes about your day-to-day leads yet, so there's no risk in starting.

2

Weeks 4 to 12

The site gets indexed and starts ranking for your local searches. Direct enquiries begin trickling in on top of whatever the platform is already bringing.

3

Months 3 to 6

Direct enquiries become a real share of new work. Most trades start noticing whole weeks where they didn't need the platform at all.

4

Ongoing

You decide. Keep the platform ticking over as a top-up, or step away once the site is reliably paying its own way. Either way, it's your call and there's no rush.

The timeline above is a general shape, not a promise. Some trades and areas move faster, some slower, depending on how much competition is already ranking locally. What holds true across almost all of them is that nobody has to choose on day one; the switch happens gradually, at whatever pace suits the diary.

Why your own site wins long term

Stop renting customers. Start owning the pipeline.

None of this is about the platforms being dishonest. It's about what actually compounds in your favour over years rather than months.

📱

Direct enquiries, not shared ones

When someone finds your site and calls, that job is yours. No race to the bottom against three others sent the same lead an hour ago.

📈

It compounds

A lead platform is a tap: money in, leads out, nothing kept. A site you own gets stronger the longer it runs, ranking for more searches over time.

Your reviews, your name

You build your own reputation on your own site, not equity in someone else's directory that you lose the day you stop paying.

💰

Predictable cost

From £49 a month, fixed, with no per-lead fees and no renewal shock. You know exactly what you're paying and what you get.

🤖

Found where people search now

Google and AI tools point people to real sites built the right way, not to your profile buried inside a platform.

🔑

You keep it if you leave

Cancel a lead platform and you vanish overnight. Your Zenlio site is yours to keep, whatever you decide down the line.

From the very beginning Dan was professional, easy to communicate with, and really took the time to understand what I wanted. He turned my ideas into a modern website I'm genuinely proud of, and made any changes quickly and without fuss. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend him.
Robert Burns ★★★★★ · Trebor Restoration · Google review
Straight answers

Questions people ask.

It depends what you want from it. It gets you enquiries quickly, which is real. But the cost isn't small: membership runs anywhere from £60 to £500 a month depending on trade and area, prices aren't public and rise at renewal, and most plans add a per-lead fee on top. A busy plumber or electrician can spend around £400 a month all in, for leads shared with three or four rivals. As a fast start it works. As your whole strategy it's expensive and you own nothing.

Because you pay once for the asset and a flat monthly fee to run it, instead of paying per lead forever. Bark charges you credits to quote jobs sent to several trades. Checkatrade stacks a membership and per-lead fees. Our sites are from £49 a month with unlimited direct enquiries and no per-lead charge, so the more work it wins, the cheaper each job gets.

Not at all. Most trades run both at first: the platform keeps leads coming while your own site builds up its rankings. Over a few months the site starts bringing enough direct enquiries that you can decide whether the platform is still worth it. No pressure either way.

That's the entire job of it. We build service and area pages targeting the searches your customers make, mark them up so Google and AI tools understand them, and show your reviews to build trust. It isn't instant like buying a lead, but once it ranks the enquiries come direct, and they're yours alone.

Faster, yes. Easier, not really. A shared lead means you're one of several quotes, usually competing on price, for a customer who was never yours. A direct enquiry from your own site is someone who found you, liked what they saw, and picked up the phone. Those convert better and haggle less.

With a lead platform, nothing. Stop paying and you disappear the same day. With a Zenlio site you own the site, the content, the domain and the reputation you've built on it. It's an asset that keeps its value whether or not you keep working with us.

Pausing still stops your listing showing to homeowners, so new leads generally stop the same way as cancelling. The usual difference is that pausing can keep your profile and existing reviews intact for a quicker restart later, rather than leads carrying on while you're not paying. Terms change and aren't published in one place, so always check directly with the platform before you decide. Either way, it's a good reminder that your visibility, and your leads, stop the moment you stop paying, paused or cancelled.

A rough patch of reviews on a platform sits inside their system, attached to their profile, not yours. What we do instead is build a site that leads with your best, most recent evidence: fresh Google reviews, real completed jobs, before-and-afters, and lets you tell the story your way rather than leaving it to a platform's review feed. It won't erase what's already out there. It does give anyone who searches for you directly a fuller, fairer picture than three old reviews taken out of context.

It depends on your trade, your area and how much competition is already ranking there, so we won't invent a number that doesn't hold for every trade. What we can say honestly: it isn't instant, expect real movement over a few months rather than days, and it builds gradually rather than switching on overnight. That's exactly why running both together during that period, the platform for immediate work, the site building for the future, is the sensible way to make the change.

For some trades, yes. A site gives Google Ads somewhere proper to send people instead of a shared platform profile that looks like everyone else's, and the enquiries from ads still land direct and unshared, the same as organic search. If you're weighing it up, the sensible order is usually to get the site live and working first, then layer in ads once there's somewhere worth sending the click. Worth a conversation about whether it earns its keep for your specific trade.

No. Reviews left on Checkatrade, Bark or similar sit inside that platform and stay there if you leave. They don't transfer to your own site or to Google automatically. That's part of the real cost of renting a reputation instead of owning one: the goodwill you've earned belongs to the platform's page, not yours. A Zenlio site is built to collect and show your Google reviews directly, which is the one review pot that's genuinely yours wherever you go.

Yes, quite a bit. If you do occasional big jobs, extensions, full rewires, large renovations, a single won job can cover months of a platform's cost outright, so even an expensive lead can pay for itself. If your work is smaller and recurring, boiler servicing, routine call-outs, the maths tightens fast, because you're paying a per-lead fee repeatedly for jobs with thinner margins. In that second case, owning a site that brings repeat and referral business direct, with no per-lead fee at all, tends to matter more, sooner.

You don't create a gap, you run both. Keep the platform ticking over exactly as it is while the site goes live and starts ranking. There's no point cutting off a working source of enquiries on day one. The whole point of the transition is that you're never relying on just one channel while the other finds its feet. Most trades only wind the platform down once the site is reliably paying its own way.

We build the trust signals that matter for a site you own: your real Google reviews, photos of completed work, and clear proof of who you are and where you operate. That's not the same as a platform's own verification badge, which only means something inside their directory. What replaces it is your own reputation, shown properly on a site that's unmistakably yours, which counts for more once someone's already looking at you directly.

Yes. Trades often start on Starter to get something live and own it, then move up as the site earns its keep and they want more pages, more area coverage, or more built into it. There's a three-month minimum on any plan, then thirty days' notice if you ever want to change or leave, so you're never locked into more than you need.

Own the pipeline. Don't rent it.

Keep the platforms running if you like. Build something of your own alongside them, and let it take over. Get a free callback, or book a 15-minute chat.

Free tools

Already weighing this up?

See exactly how your current site, or the option you're leaning toward, measures up. Free, no signup, before you decide.

Take the scorecard →